Seahawk maintains thousands of WordPress sites and works with more than 1,000 agency and hosting partners, so we often meet businesses right after a bad agency relationship has ended. The story is usually the same: the domain is registered to someone else, the theme license has lapsed, and nobody has an admin login. Almost every one of those problems was visible before the contract was signed.
This guide is for the shortlist stage. If you are not there yet, start with how to hire a WordPress agency. For each red flag you will find why it matters and what a good answer sounds like.
1. No reviews, or only reviews you cannot verify
Why it matters. Testimonials on an agency’s own website are chosen by the agency. First names with no company, or client logos with no links, tell you nothing. Real clients leave traces: reviews on Google or Clutch, a footer credit on a client site.
What a good answer sounds like. “Here are three clients with projects like yours. You can call them, and our reviews are on Google.” Read those reviews for patterns. One complaint about slow replies is noise; three about missed deadlines is how the agency works.
2. No LinkedIn company page with real people on it
Why it matters. An agency is its people. If the company page has no employees linked to it, or the staff profiles were created recently and use stock photos, the team on the website may not exist in the form described. It can also mean your project will be passed to subcontractors you will never meet.
What a good answer sounds like. Subcontracting is normal; hiding it is not. A good agency says, “Our project manager is Priya, design is in house, and a development partner handles builds. You will have Priya’s direct email.”
3. They insist on registering your domain and hosting in their own accounts
Why it matters. Whoever controls the registrar account controls your domain, and whoever controls the domain controls your website and your email. If the agency registers it in its own account and you part ways later, getting it back depends on their goodwill and their response time. The same applies to hosting: if the server is in their account, your site lives at their discretion.
What a good answer sounds like. “Create the registrar and hosting accounts in your business name and add us as a user.” Agency-managed hosting can be a good service, as long as the domain is yours and “What happens if I leave?” has a documented answer, not a negotiation. See our guides to registering a domain name and choosing a web hosting company.
4. Proprietary builders, or theme and plugin licenses only they control
Why it matters. Some agencies build on their own closed platform or a custom builder only they can edit. The site works until you want to leave, and then it has to be rebuilt. A quieter version is premium themes and plugins licensed under the agency’s account: when the relationship ends, updates and security fixes stop.
What a good answer sounds like. “We build on WordPress with standard tools, and every paid license is either bought in your name or transferred to you at handover. Here is the list with renewal dates.” Open source platforms give you the right to take your site to anyone. Our guide on why to use open source covers this in more detail.
5. No contract or written scope
Why it matters. Without a written scope, every disagreement becomes a matter of opinion. “I thought the blog was included” and “we assumed you would write the copy” are the two most common arguments we hear about, and both are settled by a single paragraph written before work starts. A friendly email thread is not a contract.
What a good answer sounds like. A proposal that lists the pages, features, integrations, revision rounds, timeline, price, and how changes will be priced. If you want to make this easy for them, send your own requirements first. Our guide to writing a website scope of work includes a template you can copy.
6. Full payment up front for a custom project
Why it matters. Paying 100 percent before work begins removes your leverage for the rest of the project. If deadlines slip or quality drops, you have nothing left to hold back.
What a good answer sounds like. A deposit to start, a payment at design approval, and the balance at launch is a common and fair structure. The sensible exception is a small, fixed-price package with a published scope, such as a migration or a speed fix. There you know exactly what you are buying before you pay, which is different from paying in full for a custom build nobody has designed yet.
7. They cannot show you live sites
Why it matters. Screenshots and mockups can come from anywhere. Live sites show what the agency actually ships: how fast it loads on a phone, whether the forms work, and whether the client still keeps their credit in the footer.
What a good answer sounds like. “Here are five live sites, what we did on each, and which ones we still look after.” Some client work really is under a nondisclosure agreement, but an agency that cannot show a single live site has either not built many or is not proud of them.
8. Vague answers about who owns the code and content
Why it matters. In many countries, including the United States, copyright in work created by an outside contractor stays with the contractor unless the contract assigns it to you. That covers custom design, custom code, and copy the agency writes. If the contract says nothing, you may not own your own website. For larger projects, have a lawyer read the ownership clause before you sign.
What a good answer sounds like. “On final payment you own the design, the custom code, and the content we write. We keep the right to show the project in our portfolio. Third-party themes and plugins stay under their own licenses, which we will put in your name.”
9. No handover plan and no care plan
Why it matters. A website is not finished at launch. WordPress core, themes, and plugins release updates constantly, and a site left alone for a year collects security holes and expired licenses. An agency with no answer to “what happens after launch?” either plans to bill hourly for every change or has not thought about it.
What a good answer sounds like. “At launch you get admin access, a backup, documentation, and a training session. If you want us to look after the site, our care plan costs this much a month and covers updates, backups, and monitoring. You are free to choose someone else.” Ask for the handover items in writing; our website handover checklist lists them. For the maintenance side, see do you need a WordPress maintenance plan.
10. Pressure tactics
Why it matters. “This price is only good until Friday” and “we have one slot left this quarter” are sales techniques, not project management. Good agencies know that a client rushed into signing is a client who will be unhappy later.
What a good answer sounds like. “Take the proposal away, ask us anything, and the price holds for 30 days.”
How to score what you find
Not every flag means the same thing. Use this rule:
- Walk away if the agency insists on owning your domain, refuses to put the scope in writing, or wants full payment up front for a custom build. No amount of talent fixes these.
- Ask harder questions if reviews are thin, live examples are few, or the team is hard to identify. A newer agency can have good reasons, and a straight answer is a good sign.
- Get it in writing for ownership, licenses, and handover. A verbal promise is not a contract clause.
Questions to send before you sign
Copy these into an email to every agency on your shortlist and compare the replies side by side:
- Can you share three live sites similar to my project, and a client I can speak to?
- Who will work on my project, and are any parts subcontracted?
- Will my domain, hosting, and all paid licenses be in my business name?
- What platform, theme, and builder will you use, and could another developer take over the site?
- What is the payment schedule, and how are changes to the scope priced?
- Who owns the design, code, and content at the end of the project?
- What will I receive at handover, and what does ongoing care cost?
An agency that answers all seven clearly and in writing is very likely one you can work with.
Where Seahawk fits
Most of these red flags come from scope and ownership being decided after the sale. WP Services, Seahawk’s productized storefront for small businesses, works the other way around: each service has a published scope and a fixed price, it is built on WordPress, and you own the result. If you want the site looked after once it is live, WP Care plans start at $29 a month. To compare other providers, see our list of the best WordPress maintenance services.
Next step
Send the seven questions above to every agency on your shortlist today. The replies will tell you more than any sales call.